ATAR vs. Alternative Pathways: What’s Right for Your Teen?
- Sharon Carr
- May 28
- 3 min read
Updated: Jun 20
As a career coach working with hundreds of teenagers and their parents each year, I often face a common question: “Should my child do ATAR or follow an alternative pathway?” This decision is significant. The right choice isn't the same for every student.
When ATAR Isn’t the Right Fit
If your child is genuinely struggling, it may be time to consider a different pathway. I don’t just mean a lack of motivation. I refer to students who find the academic load overwhelming. Continuing down the ATAR track when a student is not coping can lead to various negative outcomes.
These include a sense of failure, declining mental health, and, most damaging of all, a loss of confidence in their ability to succeed. The truth is hard: if your child doesn’t meet the minimum ATAR requirements for university entry, they may feel lost. Not only do they lack a clear next step, but they often doubt their own potential. This heavy cost comes from pursuing a path that may not suit them from the outset.
The Power of Alternatives
Many parents are unaware that numerous students excel at university without ever following the ATAR path. Programs like UniReady, OnTrack, and Curtin UniPrep offer students a second chance at university entry. Additionally, pre-apprenticeships or VET in Schools programs can propel students into skilled, high-paying careers. These paths often incur far less emotional stress compared to pursuing an ATAR that doesn’t fit them well.
In fact, many students _thrive_ when they are in the right learning environment. This setting plays to their strengths instead of exposing their vulnerabilities.
Understanding Your Teen’s Strengths
Identifying your child's unique strengths is crucial. A non-ATAR pathway might highlight their skills and interests better. Some students excel in hands-on learning environments or through vocational training instead of traditional academic programs.
This approach not only leads to successful careers but also enhances their confidence. Realizing that they have chosen a path aligned with their strengths can foster a positive mindset about their future.
What About Students Who Just Aren’t Trying?
We must acknowledge students who appear to struggle but are disengaged. These students may be capable of ATAR-level work but have switched off from their school environment. In my experience, this group can surprise everyone by excelling at university. There, they often find more independence and subjects aligned with their passions.
The key question is this: Is your child truly capable of succeeding in ATAR if they put in the effort? If the answer is yes, and they have a clear goal that requires it, pushing through is often worthwhile. However, if the answer is no—not just due to lack of effort, but because it isn’t their best learning mode—then forcing an ATAR path is unlikely to lead to positive results.
Encouraging a Mindset Shift
Encouraging your child to adopt a growth mindset is valuable. This shift involves understanding that success doesn’t have to look the same for everyone. Promoting resilience and flexibility in their career choices can open doors they may not have otherwise considered.
A Message to Parents
As a parent myself, I know how challenging it can be to let go of the idea that ATAR is the only “real” path to success. But this belief isn't accurate. There is no shame in choosing a pathway that aligns with your child’s strengths, wellbeing, and long-term goals. In fact, it often shows great wisdom.
Whether your child chooses the ATAR route or an alternative one, the most critical factor is that they move forward with confidence. They should have a sense of direction and belief in their own potential.
Seeking Guidance
If you’re unsure about what pathway is best for your teen, I’m here to help. A single session can often provide the clarity both you and your child need. Reach out, and let’s explore the best options together.
Sharon Carr – Career Smart
Comments